How Are Photographs Used as Evidence in Divorce Cases in Turkish Law?

In divorce cases, parties may need to present various pieces of evidence to substantiate their claims. Among these pieces of evidence, photographs play an important role. So, how can photographs be used as evidence in divorce cases?

Conditions for Accepting Photographs as Evidence

Certain conditions must be met for photographs submitted in divorce cases to be accepted as evidence:

Relevance: The photograph must be directly related to the subject of the divorce case. For example, a spouse alleging violence may submit photographs showing evidence of the abuse.
Accuracy: The photograph must accurately and completely depict the events. It must be proven that the photograph was not manipulated or tampered with.
Legality: The method of obtaining the photograph must be lawful. Photographs taken secretly or that invade privacy may not be accepted as evidence.
Reliability: Information such as the date, location, and conditions under which the photograph was taken must be accurate. The person who took the photograph is also important.

Uses of Photographs in Divorce Cases

Photographs can be used as evidence on various matters in divorce cases:

Violence: Photographs can support claims of physical or psychological violence.
Infidelity: Photographs showing a spouse engaging in infidelity can be crucial evidence in a divorce case.
Financial Status: Photographs depicting the financial status of the parties can be used to support claims for alimony or compensation.
Children’s Situation: Photographs showing the living conditions of the children or their relationship with their parents can be used in custody cases.

Submission of Photographs to the Court

A party wishing to submit photographic evidence in a divorce case should submit the photographs along with their petition. The original or certified copies of the photographs should be given to the court. Information such as the date, place, and conditions under which the photographs were taken must also be provided to the court.

Can Secretly Taken Photographs Be Used as Evidence in Divorce Cases?

The admissibility of secretly taken photographs as evidence in divorce cases depends on how they were obtained. Turkish law places great importance on privacy and the protection of personal data. Thus, evidence such as photographs or recordings obtained by violating a party’s privacy and personal rights is considered unlawful and cannot be evaluated. For instance, photographs secretly obtained by one spouse without the other’s consent are considered unlawful evidence by the court and will not be evaluated.

However, images and photographs obtained in public areas or in ways that do not violate privacy can be considered lawful evidence. For example, photographs taken in a public place like a shopping mall that prove a spouse’s infidelity may be accepted as evidence.

In conclusion, the admissibility of secretly taken photographs in divorce cases depends on how they were obtained and their impact on privacy. Photographs obtained lawfully and in public areas are generally accepted, while those obtained by violating personal rights cannot be used as evidence.

Methods for Determining Whether Photographs Have Been Manipulated

The methods used to determine whether photographs have been manipulated can be summarized as follows:

Expert Examination: An expert examination can be conducted to determine whether the photographs have been manipulated. This examination covers content and form analysis of the photographs and can reveal the presence of montages or digital edits.

Photo Analysis: Analysis of the metadata of the photographs can provide clues about when and with which device the photograph was taken, as well as whether it was subsequently edited. Professional photo analysis tools can detect changes made to files.
These analyses are performed by experts using special software and techniques. Here are some common methods:

1. Metadata Analysis (EXIF Data):
Each digital photograph is recorded with EXIF (Exchangeable Image File Format) data containing information such as the time, date, and camera model used. This data can provide clues about whether the photograph is original and unedited. For instance, if a photograph’s capture date is after the event it claims to depict, it raises suspicion. EXIF data can be easily examined using special software. However, it should be noted that this data can also be manipulated.

2. Visual Inspection and Consistency Analysis:
The content of the photograph is carefully examined, evaluating the consistency of elements such as light, shadow, perspective, colors, and object positions. Manipulated photographs may show inconsistencies in these elements. For example, an object’s shadow may be in the wrong direction, or a person’s body proportions may be unrealistic.

3. Error Level Analysis (ELA):
ELA analyzes the errors at different compression levels of the photograph to detect manipulation. In original photographs, compression errors are more evenly distributed, while in manipulated photographs, the distribution of these errors can be irregular. ELA is conducted using special software and interpreted by experts.

4. Copy-Move Detection Software:
This software analyzes the pixel values in different regions of the photograph to check for repeated or similar pixel groups. If copy-move operations have been performed in a photograph, this software can detect it.

5. Reverse Image Search:
The photograph can be searched using reverse image search engines like Google Images or TinEye to check if the same or similar photographs are available online. If an earlier version or a different context version of the photograph is found, it can indicate that the photograph has been manipulated.

Witness Statements: Statements from witnesses who can provide information about the time and environment in which the photographs were taken can also be considered to verify the accuracy of the photographs. Witness statements can help explain the conditions under which the photograph was taken.

In What Way and Under What Circumstances Can Children’s Photographs Be Used as Evidence in a Divorce Case?

In divorce cases, photographs of children can be used as evidence on issues such as custody, alimony, or compensation. However, certain important points must be considered for the photographs to be admissible as evidence:

1. Best Interests of the Child:
The use of children’s photographs must always prioritize the best interests of the child. Photographs should not be used in a way that negatively affects the child’s physical or emotional development. The court will prioritize the best interests of the child when deciding whether to admit the photographs as evidence.

2. Relevance and Necessity:
The photographs must be directly relevant and necessary to the subject of the divorce case. For instance, in a custody case, photographs showing the child’s living conditions, relationship with the parents, or health status can be used as evidence. Unnecessary photographs or those that violate the child’s privacy may not be accepted as evidence.

3. Anonymity of the Child:
Photographs of children should not be used in a way that clearly reveals their faces or identities. The photographs should be anonymized by methods such as blurring the faces or covering them.

4. Legality:
Photographs must be obtained lawfully. Secretly taken or unauthorized photographs may not be accepted as evidence. Particularly, photographs that violate the child’s privacy or involve abuse cannot be used as evidence.

Situations Where Children’s Photographs Can Be Used as Evidence:

Custody Cases: Photographs showing the child’s living conditions, relationship with the parents, and overall welfare can be used as evidence in determining which parent the child will live with.
Alimony Cases: Photographs depicting the child’s lifestyle, educational expenses, or health needs can be used to determine the child’s needs and the amount of alimony.
Compensation Cases: Photographs documenting any harm or loss the child has suffered, such as injuries or the treatment process, can be used as evidence.

What Are the Decisions of the Supreme Court Regarding the Impact of Photographs on the Outcome of Divorce Cases?

In one decision, the Supreme Court ruled that it is not unlawful for a spouse to present as evidence photographs, letters, diaries, or similar items found in the marital home. However, it was also stated that these pieces of evidence should be evaluated together with other evidence.

The Supreme Court has made different decisions regarding the acceptance of photographs as evidence in divorce cases and their impact on the outcome:

In one decision, the Supreme Court indicated that if a spouse’s actions contrary to the obligation of fidelity are proven with photographs, these pieces of evidence can be accepted by the court.

In another decision, the Supreme Court has made rulings indicating that photographs and correspondence taken from social media accounts without consent cannot be used as evidence. It emphasized that such evidence might be excluded as unlawful evidence.

What Are the Legal Consequences of Presenting Fake Photographic Evidence in a Divorce Case?

The legal consequences of presenting fake photographic evidence in a divorce case can be quite serious. This act can lead to both civil and criminal liability.

Civil Consequences:

Rejection as Evidence: Fake photographs will not be accepted as evidence by the court because their authenticity cannot be proven. This can negatively affect the presenting party’s case and result in the inability to prove their claims.
Damage to Credibility: The credibility of the party presenting fake evidence is significantly damaged in the eyes of the court. This can lead to other evidence being viewed with suspicion and negatively impact the overall course of the case.
Compensation Claims: If fake photographs have damaged the opposing party’s personal rights or reputation, they may file a compensation claim. In this case, the party presenting the fake evidence may be required to pay material and moral compensation.

Criminal Consequences:

Forgery of Private Documents: According to Article 207 of the Turkish Penal Code, a person who forges a private document or alters a real private document to deceive others and uses it may be sentenced to imprisonment from one to three years.
Defamation: If fake photographs are used to make false accusations against the opposing party, a defamation case can be filed under Article 267 of the Turkish Penal Code. In this case, the party presenting the fake evidence may be sentenced to imprisonment from one to four years.

What Information Should a Party Presenting Photographic Evidence Provide to Their Lawyer in a Divorce Case?

A party wishing to present photographic evidence in a divorce case should provide the following information to their lawyer:

Content of the Photographs: The party should explain what the photographs show, who is included, and their relevance to the case.
Date and Place of the Photographs: Information about when and where the photographs were taken is important for the timing and authenticity of the event.
Person Who Took the Photographs: Information about who took the photographs is important for the reliability and evidentiary value of the photographs.
Method of Obtaining the Photographs: Information about whether the photographs were obtained lawfully determines whether the evidence will be accepted by the court.
Witnesses Related to the Photographs: Information about witnesses who were present when the photographs were taken or who have knowledge of the content of the photographs strengthens the evidence.
Aspect of the Case Supported by the Photographs: Information about which claim or request in the divorce case the photographs support helps the lawyer use the evidence correctly. For example, on issues such as violence, infidelity, financial status, etc.
Privacy Violation by the Photographs: The lawyer’s assessment of whether the photographs violate privacy is important for the admissibility of the evidence.
Purpose of the Photographs: Information about the purpose of using the photographs in the divorce case (e.g., determining fault, claiming compensation, arranging custody, etc.) helps the lawyer determine the case strategy.

Use of Photographic Evidence in Divorce Cases: Explanation with Examples

Example 1: Allegation of Physical Violence
One spouse claims that the other has subjected them to physical violence. In this case, photographs showing the moments of violence or subsequent injuries can be submitted as evidence. For example, photographs of bruises, scratches, or wounds on the face or body can support the claim of violence. However, it is important that information such as the date and time the photographs were taken is accurate and that the photographs have not been manipulated.

Example 2: Allegation of Infidelity
One spouse claims that the other has been unfaithful. In this case, photographs showing the spouse being intimate with someone else can be submitted as evidence. For example, photographs of the spouse holding hands, kissing, or hugging someone else can support the claim of infidelity. However, it is important that information such as the place and time the photographs were taken is accurate and that the photographs were not taken secretly.

Example 3: Allegation of Children’s Condition
One spouse claims that the other mistreats the children or fails to meet their needs. In this case, photographs showing the children neglected or in poor condition can be submitted as evidence. For example, photographs of children in dirty clothes, malnourished, or living in inappropriate conditions can support the claim of the children’s condition. However, it is important that information such as the date and place the photographs were taken is accurate and that the photographs are presented in a way that does not violate the children’s privacy.

Example 4: Allegation of Alcohol or Substance Addiction
One spouse claims that the other has an alcohol or substance addiction. In this case, photographs showing the spouse using alcohol or substances, or photographs of alcohol bottles, drug packages, etc., can be submitted as evidence. For example, photographs showing the spouse drunk or under the influence of drugs can support the claim of alcohol or substance addiction.

Example 5: Allegation of Gambling Addiction
One spouse claims that the other has a gambling addiction and has put the family budget in a difficult situation as a result. In this case, photographs of the spouse gambling or photographs showing them at a casino can be submitted as evidence. Additionally, photographs of documents showing the spouse’s gambling debts can also be used as evidence.

Example 6: Allegation of Psychological Violence
One spouse claims that the other has subjected them to psychological violence. In this case, it can be difficult to prove psychological violence as it does not leave visible traces like physical violence. However, screenshots of messages containing insults, threatening emails, or degrading social media posts can be submitted as evidence.

For further assistance or consultation on this matter, you can contact us.